letsgolegion: (Default)
The Legion [Mods] ([personal profile] letsgolegion) wrote in [community profile] legionooc2016-03-08 04:40 am
Entry tags:

GAMEWIDE HMD

GAMEWIDE HMD MEME




This is the periodic Gamewide HMD meme!

The Gamewide HMD is optional. If you opt out of participating in the gamewide hmd, please at least have an hmd up in your journal.

This is not a love meme but it is okay to tell a player what they're doing well. Please also keep this constructive and let them know what it is you like so they know to keep doing it.

If you ask for crit please also give some to other players. While we can't enforce this because some of it will be anon, the mod team would like to ask players to please try to give at least three other players crit.

Please keep crit polite and constructive.

Please escalate severe or repeat issues to the mods, if appropriate. If repeated attempts at constructive crit don't bear any fruit, there are rules for the many possible causes of this: bad player behavior, ICA=ICC, IC /=OOC, characters having to be IC, etc. If frustrating problems consistently happen without any improvement, it is possible they're verging on a rule break, so if that is the case, rather than letting things devolve into hostility, please escalate things and contact the mods to see what steps can be taken next.
enthraller: (68)

KELLY

[personal profile] enthraller 2016-03-08 09:52 am (UTC)(link)
Here with Saralegui ([personal profile] enthraller) and Adrien Agreste ([personal profile] unfurtunate)!

Both also have anon-enabled HMDs in their journals if you're uncomfortable saying anything here, but please feel free to let me know if there's anything you think I can improve on, characterization-wise or in my writing or whatever!
iamresponding: (bucketless - amused)

[personal profile] iamresponding 2016-03-09 07:41 pm (UTC)(link)
So far I love what you've been doing with Sara. Obviously I'm canon blind but you're doing a really good job having him straddle the line between self-serving and him gradually helping and cooperating with others and from what you've said before, that seems to be what you were aiming for.

I like how he has that thing where he tries to essentially get intel on people and figure them out in case he can use it in the future, but there isn't really a solid malicious edge to it. It seems more manipulative but not like he necessarily plans to manipulate anything to hurt people in the future.

He comes off as just having this habit of doing what a manipulator would do without necessarily planning to do bad things with it.

As for Adrien aaaah, he is already a precious good-natured angel. And I love the subtle like "so talk about my muscles again" mischievous Chat streak he has even as Adrien.

So mostly just positive things! I haven't really seen anything negative so I just figured I'd let you know Sara's coming off really interesting and Adrien seems really IC so far. I'm especially excited to see how you develop Sara because his character stuff is getting more and more interesting as you go.
iamresponding: (bucketless - good humored)

TIPPLE

[personal profile] iamresponding 2016-03-08 10:16 am (UTC)(link)
My peeps:

Dipper Pines - [personal profile] captainbuzzkill
Marinette Dupain-Cheng / Ladybug - [personal profile] dupaindots
Rich Rider / Nova - [personal profile] iamresponding

For anything with Brainiac 5 or other npcs, please hit the mod comment up above.

I'm especially interested in how I'm doing with Marinette and Dipper since they're both new and I'm trying to get the hang of their voices.
whyarewehere: (Default)

[personal profile] whyarewehere 2016-03-08 03:45 pm (UTC)(link)
Dexter Grif | [personal profile] whyarewehere
Master Chief | [personal profile] prettycoolguy

I have been deathly inactive recently but am trying to get back into the swing of things as soon as I can. If there's anything you'd like to bring to my attention, please do!

[personal profile] leverageintceo 2016-03-10 08:46 am (UTC)(link)
I very much enjoyed bouncing Parker and Tadashi off of Grif! I'm technically canon-blind to him, but you strike a good balance of him being engaged with the other characters but also determined to do as little actual work as possible. He comes off as someone who's going to be reactive and fun to play with.
ringslinging: he's either fucking or getting into trouble. (Default)

sam

[personal profile] ringslinging 2016-03-09 12:20 am (UTC)(link)
Hal Jordan | [personal profile] ringslinging
Donatello | [personal profile] nerdninja

I'm new to playing both of them, so I'm trying to settle in and figure out what the heck I'm doing and I'd be glad to know if there's anything I ought to tone up or tone down.
iamresponding: (bucketless - reassuring smile)

[personal profile] iamresponding 2016-03-09 07:51 pm (UTC)(link)
I think you've been doing great with both so far. I'm fairly canon familiar with both of them, even if I haven't read everything.

Donnie comes off very sweet and thoughtful and a little dorky and that's pretty much perfect.

I'd say the only thing it'd be nice to see with him is more of his pop culture nerd interests since that's shown up in the comics but that treads away from crit and more into future CR kinda territory anyway, since Donnie's a little more nerdy with his interests rather than his speaking/references. We oughta do some stuff with that in the future in the game in general like we talked about, like with people playing nerd games.

Hal's pretty much perfect. Some comic writers can make him super bland because his character voice is kind of subtle but you're doing a good job of making him distinct like the better comic writers do. And I really like how you're handling him mentioning parallax and the heavier stuff. There's a fine balance there that could be easy to miss because it is a traumatizing thing but he's also not the type to dwell too much and you put like just the right amount of weight on it.
ringslinging: he's either fucking or getting into trouble. (Default)

[personal profile] ringslinging 2016-03-11 05:37 am (UTC)(link)
This is all very relieving! Hal especially; Donnie is playing closer to type for me, probably, so. jitterssssss

I definitely want to do the nerd games and stuff, because you're absolutely right that showing Donnie's brand of nerdiness is more about what he's doing and less about him talking like a meme loving shitlord. We should find a good piece of downtime to wedge that in somewhere.

KAYLIN

[personal profile] leverageintceo 2016-03-09 10:13 am (UTC)(link)
Here with Parker ([personal profile] leverageintceo and Tadashi Hamada ([personal profile] the_civilian).

Let me know what you'd like to see more of from these two. NPC stuff (like Kid Quantum) can be directed toward The Mods' thread above!
iamresponding: (bucketless - reassuring smile)

[personal profile] iamresponding 2016-03-09 07:58 pm (UTC)(link)
Parker's coming off amazing and makes me want to rewatch the show. Tadashi's also spot on.

One thing I just wanted to make note of just so you know it's awesome and to keep doing it is you do a really good job with Tadashi's physicality. He's a character that expresses a lot in gestures and physical movements in the movie, because hey, animated character, and you do that well with having him do certain movements, especially little absent ones. Stuff like that is great so mostly I wanted to point that out as a thing to keep focusing on as you RP him.
mirror_soldier: (Speedster)

Roach

[personal profile] mirror_soldier 2016-03-10 07:53 am (UTC)(link)
I'm just playing this cranky speedster. [ [personal profile] mirror_soldier ]

It's been a while since I've played Thad, and if there is anything I need to work on with my writing or characterization please let me know.